About 7 a.m. February 5, , a fire was discovered in one of the drying lofts where wood cured under the skylighted roof of the Old Armory. The flames glinted through, shattered the skylights and the draught roared like a Bessemer, light spattered against the dark winter’s dawn. Within the armory, the hungry tongues of flame raced as fast as a man could walk along the oilsoaked floors, curled in hot embrace around the riveted wrought-iron columns, and blistered the buff-colored Portland stone. The great steam flywheel slowly spun to a halt as smoke and flame crossed to the power house roof and licked avidly at the tallow-soaked oxhide belting. A veritable fuse pattern throughout the building, daubed with lubricant and tracing a lane from flammable roof to floor to each machine, the belting burned. In the parts room heat rose to melt brass, but not iron. Handle straps, bullet moulds, loading plungers, and trim, fused into glowing putty that meshed in the matrix cylinders from Dragoons, nipple wrenches, Navy moulds, and pocket model barrels returned from London and held as spares. The lard oil used to drench the machine-tool cutters, the sperm oil in the bluing department, the heavy grease in the maintenance room blended in a towering pyre of flame that seemed a belated pagan send-off to the soul of the late colonel, who in his lifetime had never carried insurance—and never had a fire.
With the ice-choked Connecticut River a stone’sthrow away, the fire fighting equipment somehow was not on hand when needed. With a great crash and sparks seen miles away the three top floors of the Old Armory subsided into the basements, while tons of irreplaceable machinery and essential patterns were consumed in the blaze. And so Colt’s Armory burned. Behind the fire lines, stood thousands of Hartfordites, warmed by the flames. Root was there, and Richard Jarvis, muffled up and still in his night-clothes.
The H-construction of the factory with the NewArmory or musket factory as the second limb of the letter, connected only by a thin passageway, saved the rifle muskets. Only the original armory built in along the river was destroyed, and much of the office building adjoining on Van Dyke Avenue. While Jarvis calculated the actual loss at about % of a million dollars, the stock on hand was vastly more valuable, and as he put it, they would not have taken a million dollars in cash for the armory the night before, for what was destroyed was the production line for the New Model Army .44, “the best pistol by all odds I (Colt) have ever made for military purposes.” In Colt had made 136,579 pistols; in by the end of the year, the Old Armory, rebuilt, turned out 10,406.
As previously described, in Colt’s factoryburned to the ground. Photos of the ruins reveal the total destruction of the world’s biggest private armory. The New Model Army revolver equipment was totally destroyed, but the emergency continued. From the ruins, with the assistance of many of the models and papers saved in the nearby office and in the lofts of the musket buildings which did not bum, the great pistol was returned to production.
Close examination has not narrowed down the serialof the first “post fire” NMA, but it should be in the range of about 150,000. Soon after this the so-called “Civilian Model” made its appearance. While this model is actually a clear concession to the fact Uncle Sam wasn’t buying any more shoulder stocks, collectors have confused it with the idea the gun was designed, stockless, for “civilians and officers.” The type was merely regular production after the fire. Closer study of serials should narrow this fact. One example in the 90,000 series is known; but 90,495 is cut! But the shoulder stock idea died hard. No. 176660 is fitted with a stock numbered 17660, which does not hook under the breech like the true Colt’s Patent stocks. Instead, it has a small steel hook that notches into the backstrap, and the Colt-type bottom catch for the butt. The gun is apparently post-fire, “Civilian Model,” and whether the stock was fitted at Colt’s in , or many years later, is impossible at present to say truly.
Post-fire, the barrel stamp appears a little “larger”in appearance but almost identical in dimensions. Dash terminals end it, and the marking reads the same. A very few Colts New Model Army are also found numbered with an “L” preceding the serial, and stamped address col colt London. These were marked for sale through the Colt London agency managed until after the War by Charles Frederick Dennett and Baron von Oppen.
frontiersmen, it was transformed by Springfield Armory and Colt’s factory to cartridge shooting. Modified, it became a distinctive cartridge pistol, the Model . And while the factory went back to the Navy handle for the great Frontier, not everybody approved the choice. Special long Army-like handles were fitted to target frontiers. And the Bisley handle strap is very much the proportions of the Army strap turned inside out!
Was it a bad gun? To the engineer interested intechnical details, in contrast with the solid frame models of the competition, yes. But there were no kicks from the using services. The Yankee cavalry were glad to “give ’em a jolt with a Colt.” The competition was more dangerous, and also, Root and Horace Lord, works superintendent replacing Root when the latter was elected president, had forced a gosh-awful lot of New Model Armys down Uncle Sam’s throat.
For the first time reproduced in any firearms historybook are the reconstruction drawings appended hereto, of the never-issued New Model .44 holster revolver that would have combined solid frame accuracy and strength, and metallic cartridge breech-loading capability in one basic construction. These drawings are our own completion of pencil and ink sketches preserved from destruction during one of the periodical pulpings of Colt factory records which depleted our historical sources along the Connecticut River from time to time. These sketches contain nothing basic which do not occur in the original drawings, but the originals from the John Hintiian Collection of Arms Memorabilia are too faint for reproduction.
They form the “missing link,” we believe, to whatRoot and Lord were doing before the fire.
They were readying the works to fabricate a newmodel of arm, a model so secret that it could not be heralded in advance until prototypes had been built and pilot production run through. Admittedly, this supposition sounds like the guff penned some twentyfive years ago to sell four or five fraudulent “Paterson Walker” so-called “Colts,” but we have nothing here to sell; just pencil drawings to which we have taken the liberty of adding completed barrel assemblies where a percussion gun is obviously drawn, or the hammer profile from one incomplete sketch to another more complete. It was to be a sidehammer revolver, of the type Root liked, though the patents on the earlier sidehammer revolvers produced by Colt’s were not taken out nor invented by him. In the grip form and location of the trigger guard, the relation to the New Model Army proportions at once becomes evident. While both are illustrated as percussion cylinders, the potential for fitting cartridge cylinders is obvious. The rammer is apparentiy hinged, but of the profile of the New Model series. The barrel is fixed by a cross wedge in the front frame, as in the other sidehammer pistols. Releasing the cylinder for tipping the barrel down, or upwards, is apparentiy accomplished by pulling back on the center pin, the knob of which is shown behind the hammer spur. The sideplate and hammer are arranged as in the other sidehammer guns.
This frame conception is an advance upon the earliersidehammer military pistols, being less bulky and more consistent with the approved form of the New Model .44. The solid handle frame with grips in two pieces is unusual but not unique for a Colt of this period, but the shape of the handles suggests a Remington, Rogers and Spencer, or any one of several other competitive makes. The proportions of the pistol indicate it is .44; the engineering drawings, which were full scale, show it to be about the same size as the New Model Army. The facts about this 8-inch pistol, no model of which is known, seem to have been one of the bits of Coltiana which actually did perish in the fire.
What the causes may have been for the failure ofRoot to sell more Armys to the Government is unknown. The musket works hummed day and night but pistol production in was a bare 10,406. The Trade had been hit hard with the sudden collapse of Colt’s as a supplier. By the end of April at least they had not yet delivered any guns. From Louisville, Kentucky, wholesaler John Griffith & Son wrote on April 28, : “We would take it as a favor if you would inform us about the time that you will probably be prepared to fill orders for pistols.”
The lack of endorsement on this letter prevents anysupposition as to when they could deliver, but the totals shipped that year make delivery prior to September, , very unlikely. That some service was maintained is shown by a letter to Elisha Colt, Sam’s uncle who had a financial interest in the endeavor and apparently rallied to help the old firm in its emergency. Sidehammer pocket pistol owner William Reed from Maine asked to obtain, for his gun No. 17637, “a small key with wedge to hold the cylinder pin in.” Elisha was apparently a little new at the game and endorsed this, “Do not understand your description. Please send pistol and we will repair it at once.”
The Wartime output of Colt’s in the New ModelSeries included the following patterns:
In the New Model streamlined barrel, the loading levers are esthetically uniform with the 7 1/2 -inch Navy and first type Army pattern; the small framed barrels are all to half-inch lengths, viz.: 4 1/2-inch, 5 1/2 -inch, 6 1/2-inch. The rebated cylinder allowed fitting 5-shot chambers of .36 caliber, and the bores enlarged to this size. The factory designation was simply “New Model Small .36 Cal.”
That this pistol, called by collectors “Model ,”was ready in is reflected by a letter from Colt to Commodore James Smith, U.S.N., Chief of the Bureau of Yards and Docks at Washington. Dated April 25, , the note refers to “one of our new model increased caliber,” and states: “I caused to be got ready the pocket pistol for you with all the necessary fixings some two months since ...” The round barrel creeping lever rammer pistols of this type seem uniformly to have cylinders partly fluted between chambers, on the enlarged portion of the cylinder body. A variant of this rebated frame is what, after the War, Colt’s parts lists shows was termed “New Model Pocket Pistol of Navy Caliber.” The cylinder is rebated, smooth, with stage-coach scene, octagon barrel. It is suggested by reading the voluminous numbers of orders from buyers all over the country who ordered these pistols by barrel lengths, to differentiate one model from another, as “NM 4 1/2-inch” could not be mistaken for any other pistol, that both variations are the same factory model. It is believed Colt shipped both types indiscriminately to purchasers at the same price, and though both types seem to run to about 38,000 serial numbers, and both have low numbers, no duplicate numbers have as yet been noticed. The inference they were numbered in the same series is inescapable.
It was to the original creeping lever “New ModelSmall .36” that a great honor almost occurred, in January of . During the fall preceding, Colt campaigned on the Stephen A. Douglas ticket for the governorship of Connecticut. He resisted the notion that
be inaugurated in Hartford on the New Year’s, a handsome cased pistol. The gun was the ordinary New Model Small .36 Cal., but the case was no ordinary case. Handsomely bound in embossed gold-stamped leather, it had the presentation marking “Jany 1st ” and “Dedicated by the Author to . . . ” The title, sentiments which gave Colt 80,000 Connecticut votes, and lost him the governor’s chair: “Colt on the Constitution, Higher Law, and Irrespressible Conflict.” Few indeed were the book-cases ever presented, and the occasions sad ones, for they were tokens of aid, and remembrances of failure.
That Colt was politically sensitive, as just stated,is revealed by his action in the case of the Hartford name stamps. The first of the New Model Armys had the Hartford barrel stamp, but they were not unique. This mark was applied uniformly to all of Colt’s arms —then changed back to the New York stamping.
A puzzle to collectors has been the presence of thewords address col. colt—Hartford on barrels for the octagon pocket pistols—Old Model Pocket and New Model Pocket Pistol of Navy caliber, and upon the Navy barrels of pre-Civil War manufacture. One historian, Perry Schumaker, (Colt’s Pocket Pistols, Fadco, Cal.) suggested the Hartford guns were refinished arms actually of British manufacture, and that they were so marked that Sam could determine if those made of “English steel” were satisfactory or not, by the frequency of the word Hartford appearing in connection with repairs. That this is not necessarily a true solution is shown by London agent Charles Dennett’s letter of December 21, , addressed to one of the allies, John P. Moore & Sons of New York. Dennett, in following Sam Colt’s instructions, had boxed up and prepared to ship to Moore “all the American manufactured Colts arms ... I have sent 49 cases marked [CC] #1/49 J. P. Moore & Sons New York, containing 2,000 Navy revolvers & etc. . . .
I will add for your guidance that the first 16 caseswere part of 1 to 41 inclusive sent as nearly as I can ascertain (by invoice) on or about 1st of July, , by the New York steamer to Bremen, consigned to Charles Caesar ...”
Of this lot, some were parts of arms and were reshipped back to New York later, while 16 cases remained to become part of the invoice to J. P. Moore.These 16 cases contained an assortment of arms: “These pistols, viz, 300 Navys & 750 Small (Pocket Pistols, probably 4-inch) are Hartford make & bear the stamp address col colt Hartford—
“The 1,700 with moulds & wrenches in cases#17/49 are also American make—but stamp address col colt London—& have been refinished here by hand & proved here—but are of American manufacture ...”
A solution to the problem of the different Hartfordvs New York marking is suggested in Lieutenant (later Major) William B. Hartley’s letter to Col. Colt from Washington of November 18, . Hartley, along
With the ice-choked Connecticut River a stone’s
The H-construction of the factory with the New
As previously described, in Colt’s factory
Close examination has not narrowed down the serial
Post-fire, the barrel stamp appears a little “larger”
Was it a bad gun? To the engineer interested in
For the first time reproduced in any firearms history
They form the “missing link,” we believe, to what
They were readying the works to fabricate a new
This frame conception is an advance upon the earlier
What the causes may have been for the failure of
The lack of endorsement on this letter prevents any
The Wartime output of Colt’s in the New Model
- The New Navy .36, a streamlined creeping lever
pistol en suite with the Army .44, but of course Navy size handle. A very few of these, probably under 100, had been made up with a special pattern of full fluted cylinder, when the change occurred to the smooth Navy-scene stamped cylinder in the Army series, so the Navy was changed to the Old Model cylinder to keep it uniform. Military deliveries included 1,000 New Model Navy at $22.50 February 17, , and 1,000 more April 2. An added 56 were bought January 26, , at $15, while commercial arms already in the trade were taken at varying retail prices when needed by the purchasing officers. About 40,000 New Model Navys were made. - New Model Police Pistol and New Model Pocket
Pistol of Navy Caliber. Though appearing in two forms, this is, we believe, a basic model which was supplied during the War indiscriminately. The basic
That this pistol, called by collectors “Model ,”
It was to the original creeping lever “New Model
That Colt was politically sensitive, as just stated,
A puzzle to collectors has been the presence of the
I will add for your guidance that the first 16 cases
Of this lot, some were parts of arms and were reshipped back to New York later, while 16 cases remained to become part of the invoice to J. P. Moore.
“The 1,700 with moulds & wrenches in cases
A solution to the problem of the different Hartford
![]() |
Elisha Root supported worthy causes, donated sidehammer |