Skip to main content

Some Ignorance Persisted Until Very Recently

Such confusion over gunshot injuries remained a part of Army medical gospel and was shared by some surgeons even as late as the ’s. During the Korean War the small-caliber high velocity (1,300 f.p.s. M/v)
Russian PPSH-41 submachine guns were in great use by the Chinese Communist Forces. It was not uncommon for an American soldier to be brought in by medical corpsmen with five or six bullet holes across his body, from the small .30 caliber Mauser pistol bullets the Russian burp gun fired. The relatively undamaged area about the holes, often appearing to be nothing more than little blue punctures, entrance and exit, caused a great many men to be given only temporary aid, when they needed a complete opening up and repair of the very extensive internal damage done by what was discovered experimentally to be the temporary cavity effect.

The death tolls from these insignificant-appearing wounds were out of proportion to their seeming severity, and extensive studies were conducted at Princeton University on the mechanics of gunshot wounds. High speed motion pictures using X-Ray film were hooked up to illustrate the passage of a steel ball through the leg of a live, anesthetized dog or cat; body shots were also studied.
The small bullet at velocities around 4,000 feet per second would create a prodigious cavity many times its own diameter. Enlargement of the photographs showed the ball to be tangent to the interior of this cavity only at one point: the point on the surface of the ball that was in the direction of the line of flight. The cavity extended actually forward of the position of the ball, the point of tangency internally appearing as a stem. The ball appeared to rest on this like a golf ball on a tee.
The presence of this cavity, and its form, was explained by the hydraulic nature of the mechanical damage being wrought by the bullet. Perhaps if hydraulic machinery manufacturer Colonel James T. Wilder had been approached by doctors as to why his Spencerarmed brigades were such butchers, he might have come up with an answer at least more scientific than Dr. Howard’s essay. For the fluids in the muscle are accelerated away from the ball, due to their lighter mass,
Modern skeptics are convinced of Minie ball’s devastation when exhibitions of shooting between military men armed with Garands conclude with victory to North South Skirmish Association members armed with Civil War rifle muskets. Target, 2x4 stake, is cut in half by bullets, recalls forests chopped off breast high by rifle fire in Civil War. Scene pictured is from annual fete at Ford museum’s Greenfield Village, Dearborn, Mich.
Modern skeptics are convinced of Minie ball’s devastation when exhibitions of shooting between military men armed with Garands conclude with victory to North South Skirmish Association members armed with Civil War rifle muskets. Target, 2x4 stake, is cut in half by bullets, recalls forests chopped off breast high by rifle fire in Civil War. Scene pictured is from annual fete at Ford museum’s Greenfield Village, Dearborn, Mich.
momentarily faster than the ball itself and hence the creation of the “stem” when the temporary cavity extended beyond the position of the ball momentarily. These phenomena were clearly visible at ultra high velocities, but that they existed in moderate form at lower velocities is indisputable. Nevertheless, that phenomena in physics which is known as the rate of propagation of stresses, or the speed with which the physical smashing effect (avoid use of the word “shock”) of the bullet is transmitted to the bones struck, created confusion in the minds of Dr. Howard and his contemporaries.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CHAPTER 17 The Starr Rises

From the catalog of Wallis and Wallis, British gun auctioneers ( 1962 ) at Lewes in Sussex, we read of the sale of a Starr revolver: Lot 1060 ... A 6 shot .44 Starr SA Army Perc Rev 14", brl 8", No. 51594, the top strap bearing old engraving Col. Colt Address New York, Good Condition but action As Found & frame screw not orig . Eben T. Starr of Yonkers, New York, might not have smiled at this latter day whimsey. Marking his re volver with the name of the man he dared challenge by launching a new revolving pistol business in 1858 was to him not funny. Though the modern gun bug who fraudulently marked this in the hope someone would bite on it as a hitherto unknown Colt double action revolver we trust was unsuccessful in his piracy, per haps the buyer at the Wallis and Wallis auction cherishes his purchase for what it is: one of the best and most modem revolvers of the Civil War era. Though complex inside at first glance, its parts are well thought out and reveal Star...

CHAPTER 6 Rifle Muskets: Civil War Scandals

You place me in a most embarrassing position, Mr. Secretary. How is that, Mr. Wilkeson? the gaunt-faced Penn sylvanian queried, the lines of his expression amplified by the fatigue and, somewhat, disappointment with which he laid down his role as Secretary of War for Mr. Lincoln. Because, Mr. Cameron, the newspaperman re sponded, your contract for rifle muskets with the Eagle Manufacturing Company of Mansfield, Connecticut is for only 25,000 arms, and my friends there, whom I induced to engage in this business in expectation of your issuing a further order, as your assistant Mr. Scott assured me you would, will be sorely embarrassed in their operations on this small amount. Indeed this is bad news to me, Mr. Wilkeson, War Secretary Simon Cameron sympathetically observed, as he stuffed papers from his desk drawer into a large portfolio, scanning them briefly, consigning some to the waste basket. But as you can see, I am leaving office today; I believe Mister Stanton, who repla...

French and Belgian Arms

French and Belgian materiel was considered next best to the Enfields, though the types and calibers were more varied than either Enfield or Austrian Lorenz arms. Basic pattern for the best rifles of both France and Belgium was the “carabine” of Captain Minie. Minie’s designs had exerted profound changes in the world’s small arms armament. That change was ably summed up by lexicographer Thomas Wilhelm after the War when he prepared his military dictionary. Said Wilhelm, “Minie Rifle. A species of fire-arm, invented by Capt. Minie, from whom it receives its name. It is certain in aim, and fatal in its results at 800 yards.” The claim was, if anything, inferior to the real capability of the Minie rifle. France in 1861 possessed a surplus of many arms. During the 1840 ’s the temporary procurement of guns designed by Thouvenin, Pontchara, Minie, and others kept the arsenals busy and the soldiers active testing them. Then came the Crimean War and France’s involvement on the side of Gr...